If you die holding investments in your own name, they usually pass through your estate first.

In Ontario that means estate administration tax of 1.5% on the value above $50,000, a court process before your executor can distribute anything, and a record of what you owned that can be viewed by others. A segregated fund is an investment held inside an insurance contract. Because it is insurance, it can pay a named beneficiary directly, may be protected from creditors in some circumstances, and guarantees that a set portion of your deposits comes back at maturity or on death. Those features have a cost. Whether a segregated fund suits you depends on whether they solve a problem you actually have.

How segregated funds work

How a segregated fund works

You make deposits into a contract issued by a Canadian life insurance company. The money is invested in one or more underlying funds holding shares, bonds or both. Those assets are held separately from the insurer's own, which is where the name comes from.

The value of your contract rises and falls with the underlying investments. What makes it different is what happens at two points.

  • At maturity, usually at least ten years after your deposit, you receive the market value or the guaranteed amount, whichever is higher. Guarantees are typically 75% or 100% of deposits.
  • On death, your beneficiary receives the market value or the death benefit guarantee, whichever is higher.
  • Withdrawals reduce the guaranteed amount. If you cash in the contract before maturity, you receive the market value less any charges, and the maturity guarantee no longer applies.

The four features that matter

Guarantees at maturity and on death

The guarantee puts a floor under your deposits over a long holding period. It protects against a sustained fall, not day-to-day market movement. Some contracts let you reset the guarantee to a higher market value, which usually restarts the maturity period.

Direct payment to your beneficiaries

With a named beneficiary, the death benefit is generally paid outside your estate. In Ontario that usually means no estate administration tax on that amount, no wait for probate, and no inclusion in estate court filings. For scale, Ontario's estate administration tax on a $1 million estate is $14,250.

Potential protection from creditors

Where a family class beneficiary (a spouse, child, grandchild or parent) or an irrevocable beneficiary is named, a segregated fund contract may be protected from the owner's creditors under provincial insurance law. This protection is not automatic. It can be challenged if the contract was bought when financial difficulty was already known, and it may not apply to amounts owed to the Canada Revenue Agency. If creditor protection is your main reason for considering a segregated fund, take legal advice first.

Protection if the insurer fails

Segregated fund guarantees are covered by Assuris, the not-for-profit organization that protects Canadian life and health insurance policyholders. If a member insurer fails, Assuris guarantees you retain up to $100,000 or 90% of the promised guarantee, whichever is higher.

What segregated funds cost

Segregated funds usually carry higher annual fees than comparable mutual funds, because part of the fee pays for the insurance guarantees. Contracts with a 100% guarantee generally cost more than those with 75%. Some contracts also apply charges if you withdraw early. That cost is paid every year the contract is held. It is only worth paying if what it protects is worth more to you than the return it gives up. For someone buying purely to avoid probate on a modest estate, the extra fees over ten years can exceed the tax saved. For a business owner with real liability exposure, or a family whose estate would otherwise be tied up for months, the numbers can look very different.

Who suits segregated funds

Who segregated funds may suit

  • Business owners and incorporated professionals whose personal savings could be exposed to business creditors.
  • People who want specific savings to reach named family members directly, privately and without delay.
  • Investors close to retirement who could not recover from a large fall in the years before they need the money.
  • Families with heirs or assets in more than one country, where a simpler Canadian estate reduces the work for executors abroad.

They are usually a poor fit if you may need the money within ten years, if keeping costs as low as possible is your priority, or if you are saving inside an RRSP or TFSA where a beneficiary can already be named and creditor protection is not a concern.

How we approach it

Before any contract is discussed, we look at the problem you want to solve. That means who you want to benefit and how quickly your business and liability exposure, how long the money can stay invested, and what the additional fees would cost over that period compared with the tax, delay or risk they would remove where a segregated fund does not come out ahead we will say so.

FAQs

Explore answers to some of the most frequently asked questions about Segregated Funds

Segregated Funds

01Are segregated funds guaranteed?

Part of your deposits is guaranteed, usually 75% or 100%, but only at maturity or on death. Before then the value moves with the market, and withdrawals reduce the guarantee.

02Do segregated funds avoid probate?

Where a beneficiary other than your estate is named, the death benefit is generally paid directly and falls outside the estate for probate purposes in Ontario. Naming your estate as beneficiary removes this advantage.

03Are segregated funds protected from creditors?

They may be, where a family class or irrevocable beneficiary is named and the contract was not bought to avoid known debts. Protection is not guaranteed and should be reviewed with a lawyer.

04How are segregated funds taxed?

Held outside a registered plan, the income and capital gains allocated to you each year are taxable. Segregated funds can also be held inside an RRSP, RRIF For TFSA, where the usual rules for those plans apply.

05What's the difference between a segregated fund and a guaranteed investment fund?

There is no structural difference. Guaranteed investment fund is a name some insurers use for their segregated fund contracts.

06What happens if the insurance company fails?

Segregated fund assets are held separately from the insurer's own assets. The guarantees are also protected by Assuris up to $100,000 or 90% of the promised amount, whichever is higher.